[Dr. Zafar Ahmed, Anushaktinagar Mumbai 400094, India (zai-alpha@hotmail.com) April-04,2020]
4 Parts, Total Reading Time: 20 min.
(I)
In September of 2002, I was invited to deliver some lectures in a teachers’ training at a university. With several hasty and hectic experiences earlier in the past, I decided to reach the station early to catch my train. But it was a bit too early as I was the first one to reach the platform, after some time the train came, I searched for the AC 2T compartment. But my name did not feature in the list of passengers pasted on the door. Attendants came to clean and furnish the compartment, I asked them too. Other passengers started coming in. The one on my neighbouring berth also came and sat, I asked him my doubt, he could only say “ let the TC come.” I was very worried, as some 20 minutes or so were left for the train to depart. I went to check the list on the platform which was just pasted. Not seeing my name there also, I had to examine my ticket and I was shocked to see that I was there on the platform one month before, as the month of the booked travel was October!
I did not have enough cash to buy another AC 2T ticket. I also wondered whether an ordinary window would cancel my reserved ticket of October and gave me one for that day of September, it was 2145 hrs or so then. I looked desperately at the Inquiry counter of VT which was unmanned. I tried getting cash from the ATM using my favourite credit card but in vain. Those days windows wouldn’t accept credit card payments. So I decided to try and get a general class ticket. I got into the long que for a ticket, there were some 20 people ahead of me and only 15 minutes left for the train to whistle away.
Worse, the clerk at the window was laughing, shouting and making some gestures at the que. I was getting more nervous, with my blood boiling I thought of rattling him up after getting the ticket, If at all I got it. Thankfully, my turn came and I got the ticket, then I asked that sadist as to why the hell he was so excited. He said “Sir, look at that window, just no one is there to buy tickets. and they are overcrowding here, I have been trying to tell all of you this only.” I hurriedly replied how would we know and understand such a great message . (In fact, we try to see a crowd to join it and that has become our habit. If there is no crowd, we are not sure and we lose faith.). I did tell the que about what he was trying to convey.
After getting the ticket. I ran and I could board the same train, just then it whistled away. This time, I entered the nearest one — a reserved sleeper class. After negotiating with the TC, I even got a berth: Corruption buys convenience, I couldn’t have done anything else.
(II)
It was around 4 AM, my station had come and there I was supposed to locate a white ambassador with a certain number, which I did well. The head of department (HOD) himself came to receive me. On the way to the university, HOD kept smiling and listening to my episode. But to me the HOD appeared to be too experienced as he found my story to be normal! Also, he did not react/ respond to other things I told him. I thought him to be strange. Reaching the guest house and before leaving me, he politely informed me that my lectures were scheduled at 10:00 AM and that a car would come to fetch me there.
I reached the department and was brought to HOD’s plush office with a feudal setup. Those days, tickets were cancelled only at windows on VT, so I thought of taking HOD’s help for the cancellation of my October-ticket and for the confirmation of my return journey ticket. But the HOD was totally unaware of my October-ticket, and he wanted to know the matter! I again narrated my episode to him, this time he was laughing like mad. He found my story to be hilarious. To my surprise, I noticed that the HOD had a hearing aid and in those wee hours of morning, he was not wearing it!!
(III)
I was then introduced to my audience waiting for me. For lecturing, instead of bombarding them with new topics, I deliberately chose some old topics which were familiar to them in their post-graduation. Then the onus of telling them something new, rare and exciting fell upon me and I did succeed in holding my audience well. Three-hours of my lectures were spaced by two 15 minutes breaks and a good number of questions were asked. I managed answering all excepting two. I frankly, threw those two questions open for anyone to answer: then, later or never. I gave my audience my email-id to interact.
At the end of lectures, four young men came to tell me that they had already studied those things and that I should have lectured them on some new topics. I promptly asked them if everything went up well and right, as they knew those things already. They perhaps got a hint of my sarcasm they hurried saying “yes, yes” and further I asked them if they had answers to the two nuts, they were further let down. But I wondered as to what kind of teachers they were who came to know something which they had not studied, they would rather go for research instead of teaching. With old things already not clear! they perhaps wanted to explore new things instead!! I could gauge that they were faking!
After lunch, there was a valedictory session. Seven of my audience and three observers spoke about delightful and interesting points about my lectures. I requested the introduction of those four men, they turned out to be 4 of the 10 lab-instructors of their colleges who were graduates and special invitees in that programme, whereas others were regular teachers, who were postgraduate or above.
Next, I was requested to say a few words. I said “teachers must keep reading, listening, teaching and discussing the same things over and over again to gain knowledge, understanding, wisdom and intuition; apart from just the information which they were imparted when they were students. A good piece of research is not unlikely after a class-room discussion. Research is not essentially getting registered under someone, in some institution and working out a Ph. D. Even a graduate can keep on working on one’s own, one may be awarded a D. Sc. Or D. Litt. by a university.” They clapped and I was happy to notice that the HOD was wearing his hearing-aid then.
That day, there was a national Bandh following the unfortunate intrusion of terrorists in the Swaminarayan temple but I could get a good auto-rickshaw driver who took me around the historical city for site-seeing. Among several spots I visited, two things stood apart: the red ! Taj-Mahal and the perpetually flowing water-line that apparently defied hydraulics just by the grace of some Baba !!
He then dropped me at the station. May be, because of the Bandh my return journey ticket got confirmed. (Bandhs are always not inconvenient). To my surprise, I found those four young men were smiling and waiting for me there to bid me good bye. It seemed they liked what I said in the valedictory function.
I surely had a memorable tour. The next day, I got an email of thanks from the HOD. He also asked me if those four young men came to see me off! It seems HOD took them to task and sent them to the station as a punishment!
Friends, after working for about 20 years, yours truly himself was awarded D.Sc. from Mumbai University in 2009 by submitting his published papers in 2007.
(IV)
In 2014, one intern came to me for two months or so I asked him to work on one of the questions asked there in the teachers’ training. He worked well and while leaving the young man gave me a good clue. We worked further online and submitted it to an arXiv and a Journal. The Journal declined it but it has been doing very well in the arxiv.
Just a B.Sc. and a school-teacher from Nashik named KAPREKAR (1905-1986) proposed several interesting results with numbers. He invented a special number (6174) and its repercussions. This number is called KAPREKAR number. Indeed, Kaprekar did not require any Ph. D/D. Sc. Maybe it was also because his name was already D. R. Kaprekar.
One lady physicist from my batch in my Centre was a Ramanujan-medalist in her graduation and she was among top-four in my batch. She joined nuclear research and got married to a CA. In the third semester of her pregnancy she even ventured to fly to Calcutta to participate in a competitive colloquium, there she bagged an award. Eventually, she had to resign from science as her husband wanted to go to an oil-rich country for greener pastures. She was bringing up two children later they all migrated to Canada. With children grown up, she wanted to re-kindle the old flame (nuclear research) by taking admission for a Ph. D. there.
I was in the middle of my career when she asked me to write a Letter of reference! Though I felt honoured, yet I was surprised and afraid as to whether my report would work well. Several senior nuclear physicists would have liked to write a good report for her whereas I was a mathematical physicist and that too a peer! Finally, I wrote the Letter/report, she got admission and finished her Ph. D. It was sometime then, she was invited to BARC to deliver a lecture. In USA, she worked for four years in a strategic nuclear organization. Later, doctors advised her to keep away from nuclear-radiation. She took to teaching. Presently, she is a Professor in a nursing college where she teaches Math. She paints and sings (mostly classical Carnatic) very well. Recently, she has written articles on COVID-19 in Linkedin using Math, nuclear physics and data.
Dilraj Kaur, a popular playback singer of B’wood disappeared from the arena, I wondered why?! Once she was invited to BARC as a judge for a completion, in reply to my question she said: she went back to Lucknow for a Ph. D. ! in music. I guess, she may have been too simple and not a B’wood-savvy.
Later, I really felt the craze for doing a Ph. D. gradually, when one young member of my division came to inform me that one M.Sc. in Math from Calcutta had passed GATE, NET and SET very well and she desired to do a Ph. D. under me. Earlier, I had declined a similar case in Phys. from Calcutta. If one is already professionally into science, it is fun to work with him/her. In fact, I was always afraid to bring a new one into the risky world of science. So, I told him that it would not be possible.
After some time, he came back to surprise me by saying “ Sir, she is my fiancé! we did M.Sc. together from IIT-Kh but I was in Physics.” I again responded with “NO” and suggested him that she could instead become a teacher. Next time he came with sweets to tell me that they got married. I thought that the idea of her Ph. D. would melt down soon.
After sometime, the young man came yet again with the same request. This time I told him that BARC did not recognize Mathematics, Pharmaceutics and Bio-Technology as a subject yet, though these things were being practiced considerably in Trombay and that her admission was not possible.
I suggested that she could work from home with me without a formal registration. They agreed. The husband also made arrangements so that she could attend my lectures in Training School. She started working, two papers happened to be published with her, subsequently.
They took my permission and these two papers, to try Mumbai University in both Maths and Physics departments. Despite sympathies of some people, funny things happened and she failed to register there too.
They tried some universities in WB, only JU obliged her after interviews and formalities. She had to undergo their Pre-Ph.D. course work. Later, she worked hard and we could publish some 6 papers with me. Last year, I was invited to sit in her defense viva. There, I met two senior/retired Quantum-Mechanists who have been keeping her Project-Ph.D. afloat. After submitting her thesis she took up teaching in a college. Last year, in December, she has been awarded Ph. D., with a less than one year old son in her lap.
While correcting drafts of her thesis I restrained her and diluted the portions in the acknowledgements where she was kind of claiming that she was born to do Ph. D!
Anyway, now even I can boast of producing at least one Ph. D. The other bright young man could have been my second one in this regard, had the system been kind to him. Actually, his case requires a film to be made. If I can write one, then I will approach Raju Hirani of MUNNA BHAI MBBS fame, to make it!
Thanks for your read, you may forward it.. Lock-dowm and stay safe for now.